Soft November daylight fills a new home's neutral kitchen and oak dining nook, with a quiet backyard visible through the window.

Symphony Bay's Final Phase and the Price of a New Lake Geneva Home

  • November 19, 2026

Next to Big Foot Beach State Park sits a private clubhouse with a screened porch, a gas fire pit, a bocce pit and a bar built to look like the stern of a wooden lake boat. Its developer calls it Buttons Bay Club, says it is open, and says the state park beach is "just feet" from the property. The homes it serves are going up at the corner of Townline Road and North Road. Those homes sit inland, and owners reach the lake through the shared club. That arrangement is the first thing to understand about Symphony Bay, a single-family subdivision on the north edge of the City of Lake Geneva that is now down to its final phase.

Symphony Bay's advertised starting prices sit below Walworth County's resale median. The base price buys a floor plan, though. What a household lives with every day depends far more on which lot the house sits on and on how the lake is reached. For anyone shopping new homes around Lake Geneva this winter, those two things decide the purchase.

The Last Phase on the North Edge

The Lake Geneva City Council has approved the final phase of Symphony Bay, according to Lake Geneva Regional News. Phase 8 has 128 single-family homes at the southwest corner of Townline Road and North Road. The city earlier annexed about 70 acres from the Town of Bloomfield to make room for it, Lake Geneva Regional News reported. The Plan Commission approved the final plat at a special meeting on January 6, 2026, and the plat went to the City Council six days later, on January 12. Local reporting names Fairwyn Ltd. as the developer.

That word "final" matters for timing. Once the 128 Phase 8 homesites are spoken for, this subdivision has no more land to sell. Anyone who wants a new home in Symphony Bay is choosing from this phase's plat.

The Price List Starts Below the County Median

The developer's floor plan page lists five designs. Each comes with a size and a starting price.

Plan Size Bedrooms Advertised starting price
Villa 1,345 sq. ft. 2 bed, 2 bath from the mid-$300s
Mariner 1,590 sq. ft. 2 bed, 2 bath from the mid-$300s
Chesapeake 1,700 sq. ft., or 2,347 with the second floor option 2 bed, 2 bath from the upper $300s
Regatta 1,750 sq. ft. 3 bed, 2 bath from the upper $300s
Spinnaker 1,940 sq. ft. 2 bed, 2 bath, optional third bedroom from the low $400s

Now set those numbers beside the resale market. The Wisconsin REALTORS Association's September 2026 county report put Walworth County's median sale price for that month at $419,750. That was up 15.0% from $365,000 in September 2025. The same table shows 170 county sales in September 2026, up from 129 a year earlier. Months of inventory fell from 6.0 to 4.6, and average days on market dropped from 85 to 72.

One month is a small sample, and the year-to-date figure moves less. From January through September 2026, the Walworth County median was $415,950, up 8.6% over the same stretch of 2025, on 1,176 sales.

Both measures point the same way. Resale homes in the county cost more this year than last, they sell faster, and fewer of them are on the market at any one time. Against that, a new 1,590-square-foot home advertised from the mid-$300s looks like a bargain. The county median, though, describes every kind of resale home sold in the county, with whatever upgrades and landscaping earlier owners added. The Symphony Bay figure describes one plan at its starting specification. The two numbers are not measuring the same product.

What "From" Leaves Out

On the developer's own spec sheets, many of the features a buyer pictures in a lake-area home are listed as options. A fireplace is optional on all five plans. So is a gourmet kitchen. Cathedral ceilings are optional on the Mariner, Chesapeake, Regatta and Spinnaker. The Chesapeake's jump from 1,700 to 2,347 square feet comes from an optional second floor. The Regatta's deluxe bath is an option too.

Garage size depends on the lot. Every plan comes with a two-car garage. The three-car garage option is available only on what the developer calls Orchestra Series homesites. A buyer who needs room for a boat trailer or a third vehicle is shopping a subset of lots, not a floor plan.

The developer's site also states that prices, availability, assessments and fees can change. A buyer comparing a new home with a resale should get the current price for the specific lot and the options they want, along with the current association fee schedule in writing. That figure is the one that belongs next to the county median.

The North Road Edge

Lot choice matters most along the eastern edge of Phase 8, where homes back toward North Road. The Phase 8 landscaping plan put deciduous and coniferous trees along every lot next to North Road, plus a cluster of trees along North Road south of Bach Way to screen the lots from neighbors across the street, Lake Geneva News reported. The shade trees named in the plan are sugar maple, bur oak and littleleaf linden. City staff asked for more screening along that east side. At the City Council, members added trees and a bush buffer back into the Phase 8 plan, and city staff were set to review a revised landscape plan. The item was last discussed on February 9, 2026.

Two homes with the same floor plan and the same base price can feel different depending on what sits behind the back fence. With a resale home, you can see that on the first visit. With a new build, the plat and the landscape plan show it, so ask to see both before choosing a lot.

The Lake Comes Through a Clubhouse

Buttons Bay Club is how Symphony Bay owners get to Geneva Lake. Beyond the porch and fire pit, the developer lists an outdoor shower and large changing rooms for a full day of swimming, three deck seating areas, a pergola over the outdoor kitchen and dining area, and indoors, a grand fireplace and a pool table.

Closer to home, the developer's community page describes walking paths through a Woodland Conservancy, a planned bark park near it, and a clubhouse with a fitness center and lap pool. That page also says the Geneva Lake Shore Path "will connect with Symphony Bay." Several of those features are described as planned, so a buyer should ask which ones are built.

Owning near the lake through a shared club differs from owning frontage. A lakefront buyer pays for the shoreline and often a pier. In the city, a buyer who wants a municipal boat slip works through a separate city system on its own timeline, which we covered in In Lake Geneva, the House and the Dock Are Two Different Purchases. Our guide to waterfront versus water access in Lake Geneva lays out how those categories differ.

What Comes After Phase 8

The next large housing proposal near the city is still at an early stage. Peller Investments, LLC has proposed a mixed-use neighborhood on 100 acres of vacant land between Highway 12 and Grand Geneva, Walworth County Community News reported on October 20. The plan includes single-family homes, townhomes, senior housing, attainable housing, about 25 acres of open space and trails, and business space near Highway 12. The site is in the Town of Lyons, right next to the city line. The developer first asked for an amendment to the Future Land Use Map, and city staff recommended scheduling a joint public hearing with the Common Council.

On the other side of town, Walworth County Community News reported in May that Lennar had proposed more than 200 single-family homes next to Palmer Road at Geneva National, at the conceptual plan stage. We looked at what that debate showed about Geneva National in What the Lennar Fight Reveals About Who Pays for Geneva National's Water. Of the three, only Symphony Bay's final phase has an approved plat and a published price sheet.

If you're comparing a Symphony Bay homesite with a resale home elsewhere in Lake Geneva, Shannon Blay and the Keefe + Blay team would be glad to talk through the lots and how they compare. Owners thinking about selling while the county's resale market is this tight can start with a home valuation.

Work With Shannon

Shannon Blay is dedicated to helping you find your dream home and assisting with any selling needs you may have.

Follow Us on Instagram